Gilmário's car key

Here's a description of the contestant's attempt. Someone's probably working on collecting some images to illustrate it.

Gilmário brings in a spare car key. He says that he took it accidentally, and did not realise he had kept the key in his jacket pocket, and since he had already sworn to the key’s owner that he had not taken it, he couldn’t return it, as he believes his friend will declare their friendship over once he finds out Gilmário did in fact have the key. When pressed, Gilmário reveals that the friend had lectured his wife and kids about personal property, and the missing key had even caused a temporary rift between the friend and the friend’s brother. Vasco awards him fifth place, because by Gilmário’s own admission, the friend had a spare key.

(Written by Jenny R and edited by Karl Craven)